Private Operating Foundations vs. Non-Operating Foundations: Key Differences for Philanthropic Success
In the world of charitable giving strategies, private foundations offer individuals and families a unique opportunity to create a lasting legacy while supporting charitable causes they care about.
Read here on private foundations, generally.
In this article, I discuss the major differences between a private foundation and a private non-operating foundation.
Private foundations are a powerful tool for individuals and families looking to make a lasting impact through philanthropy.
Within this category, there are two distinct types of private foundations: Private Operating Foundations and Private Non-Operating Foundations. While both are classified under Section 501(c)(3) of the Internal Revenue Code and serve charitable purposes, they differ significantly in structure, operations, and goals.
At Bridge Law, LLP, we guide clients in choosing the right type of foundation to align with their philanthropic and financial objectives. In this article, we’ll explore the differences between operating and non-operating foundations to help you make an informed decision.
What is a Private Operating Foundation?
A Private Operating Foundation is a type of private foundation that devotes most of its resources to directly carrying out its charitable activities, rather than simply making grants to other organizations. Examples of operating foundations include museums, research institutions, libraries, and charitable hospitals. In this respect, a private operating foundation is more similar to a public charity.
Key Features of Private Operating Foundations:
- Direct Charitable Activities: Operating foundations are required to spend a significant portion of their income directly on their own charitable programs or activities. At least 85% of the foundation’s adjusted net income must be used for these purposes.
- Independence: Operating foundations often run their own programs, giving donors more direct control over how their charitable contributions are utilized.
- Tax Benefits for Donors: Donations to operating foundations receive more favorable tax treatment than non-operating foundations. For example:
○ Cash donations are deductible up to 60% of a donor’s adjusted gross income (AGI).
○ Donations of appreciated securities are deductible up to 30% of AGI.
| Feature | Operating Foundation | Non-Operating Foundation |
For a more detailed discussion of the tax benefits to various groups, click here.
4. Flexibility in Activities: These foundations are ideal for donors who want to actively participate in charitable work, whether through funding research, creating educational programs, or running cultural institutions.
What is a Private Non-Operating Foundation?
A Private Non-Operating Foundation, by contrast, primarily serves as a grant-making entity. It does not typically conduct its own charitable programs but instead provides financial support to public charities and other nonprofit organizations.
Key Features of Private Non-Operating Foundations:
- Grant-Making Focus: Non-operating foundations distribute grants to support the programs of other charitable organizations. These grants must align with the foundation’s mission.
- Annual Distribution Requirement: Non-operating foundations are required to distribute at least 5% of their net investment assets annually for charitable purposes. This amount includes grants, administrative expenses, and qualifying distributions.
- Tax Benefits for Donors: Contributions to non-operating foundations are subject to stricter deduction limits:
- Cash donations are deductible up to 30% of AGI.
- Donations of appreciated securities are deductible up to 20% of AGI.
- Ease of Management: Non-operating foundations are simpler to manage since they do not conduct programs directly. They are ideal for donors who prefer a hands-off approach or wish to support multiple charities through grants.
| Primary Function | Conducts its own charitable programs | Makes grants to public charities |
| Tax Deduction Limits | Higher (up to 60% of AGI for cash contributions) | Lower (up to 30% of AGI for cash contributions) |
| Annual Payout Requirements | At least 85% of income spent on direct activities | At least 5% of net investment assets |
| Level of Involvement | Active in program development and operations | Passive, focused on funding other charities |
| Best For | Donors wanting hands-on control over programs | Donors preferring grant-making flexibility |
Choosing the Right Foundation for Your Goals
The decision to establish a private operating or non-operating foundation depends on your philanthropic vision, desired level of involvement, and financial considerations. Here are some key factors to consider:
- Philanthropic Goals: If you want to directly manage and control charitable programs, an operating foundation may be the right choice. If your goal is to support a variety of causes and organizations through grants, a non-operating foundation is more suitable.
- Tax Deduction Preferences: Operating foundations offer higher tax deduction limits for contributions. Donors with significant income or appreciated assets may find these limits advantageous.
- Complexity and Management: Operating foundations require more active involvement and administrative oversight, while non-operating foundations are simpler to manage, making them ideal for passive philanthropists.
- Legacy and Longevity: Both types of foundations allow you to create a lasting charitable legacy, but operating foundations may provide a more visible and personal connection to your charitable work.
How Bridge Law, LLP Can Help
Establishing and managing a private foundation requires careful planning and a thorough understanding of tax laws and regulations. At Bridge Law, LLP, we work with clients to design foundations tailored to their unique goals, whether they choose to create an operating or non-operating foundation. Our experienced attorneys provide guidance on compliance, administration, and maximizing the impact of your philanthropy.
Ready to Start Your Giving Journey?
We offer a one-hour $500 charitable gift journey consultation, where we review for you all of your potential gifting strategies. Learn more about how Bridge Law, LLP can help you leave a lasting impact.